Private adoption sounds simple: a child is cared for by someone who is not the biological parent, and everyone agrees that the arrangement is best for the child. In Indonesia, however, adoption is not completed merely because a family hands over a child or signs a private agreement. The law treats adoption as a serious legal process because it affects identity, family relationships, inheritance, parental responsibility, and the child’s long-term welfare.
When you and I discuss “private adoption,” we usually mean an arrangement made directly between biological parents, relatives, guardians, and prospective adoptive parents. It might involve a family member raising a child, a direct placement with another family, or an informal agreement without an agency. These arrangements may happen socially, but they do not automatically create a legally recognized adoption.
The central principle is simple: the child’s best interests come first.
The Main Legal Foundation
The primary legal framework is Law No. 23 of 2002 on Child Protection, as amended by Law No. 35 of 2014 and later amendments, including Law No. 17 of 2016. The law recognizes adoption as a transfer of care, education, and upbringing from the child’s biological family, guardian, or another responsible person to adoptive parents.
The definition is important because adoption does not mean that adults can privately transfer ownership of a child. A child is not property. Adoption transfers legal responsibility for care and upbringing, not the child’s human identity or dignity.
The detailed procedure appears in Government Regulation No. 54 of 2007 on the Implementation of Adoption. This regulation sets requirements for the child, the prospective adoptive parents, consent, social investigations, court involvement, and government approval.
A valid adoption normally requires a court decision or court order. Without that decision, the prospective parents may be caring for the child, but their legal position remains uncertain.
Why Private Arrangements Create Risks
A private arrangement may feel more personal and less complicated than going through official channels. But skipping the legal process can create serious problems later.
The biological parents may change their minds. The child may need medical treatment, schooling, a passport, or official identification. The adoptive parents may separate or die. Relatives may later challenge the arrangement. The child may also discover that the adoption was kept secret or that important information about their biological family was hidden.
A private document signed by the adults may show consent, but it does not replace the required court order. It also cannot remove the child’s legal rights or change the child’s lineage simply because the adults agree.
That is why I would treat a private arrangement as a temporary care arrangement, not as a completed adoption.
Requirements for Prospective Adoptive Parents
Government Regulation No. 54 of 2007 sets important requirements for prospective adoptive parents. They should generally be physically and mentally healthy, between 30 and 55 years old, of good character, and not previously convicted of a serious offence.
They should also generally have been married for at least five years, have the same religion as the prospective child, and have suitable economic and social conditions. The regulation also requires written consent from the child’s parent or guardian, the child’s consent where appropriate, and a written statement that the adoption is for the child’s best interests.
The regulation also limits adoption by a same-sex couple and contains requirements concerning existing children and the prospective parents’ ability to provide proper care.
These requirements may appear strict, but they exist for a reason. Adoption should not be used to solve an adult’s financial problem, conceal an unlawful transaction, obtain cheap domestic labour, or create an informal immigration arrangement. The process must focus on safety, stability, affection, education, health, and the child’s future.
The Role of the Biological Parents
The biological parents’ consent is important, but consent alone is not enough. They must understand the legal and practical consequences of adoption. Consent should be voluntary and free from pressure, payment, deception, or exploitation.
A parent cannot validly “sell” a child. Any payment or benefit connected to the transfer must be examined carefully because it may suggest trafficking, coercion, or an unlawful arrangement.
The child’s personal history should also be preserved. Birth records, medical information, family background, and important identity details should not be erased. Even where the child is raised by adoptive parents, knowledge about biological origins may matter for health, identity, emotional development, and future relationships.
The process should therefore protect both the child and the biological family. It should not create a situation where the child is cut off from essential information without a proper legal reason.
The Marriage Law and Adoptive Families
The 1974 Marriage Law, as amended by Law No. 16 of 2019, does not provide the complete adoption procedure. However, it remains relevant because it regulates parental responsibilities, the status of children, marriage, family property, and the obligations of parents.
Article 45 requires parents to maintain and educate their children as well as possible. That principle supports the broader rule that adults raising a child must provide care, education, protection, and moral guidance.
The Marriage Law also becomes relevant when adoptive parents divorce. A divorce does not automatically remove their responsibility toward an adopted child. The child’s welfare must remain central, including living arrangements, education, health costs, and emotional support.
If an adoptive parent dies, the family must also understand how the child’s property rights operate. Adoption may create parental responsibilities, but inheritance consequences depend on the applicable legal system and the terms of the court order.
Islamic Law and the Compilation of Islamic Law
For Muslim families, the Compilation of Islamic Law, or KHI, provides important guidance. Article 171(h) defines an adopted child as a child whose daily care, education, and other needs are transferred from the biological parents to adoptive parents through a court decision.
This wording reinforces the point that a court decision is essential. Informal care alone does not create the full legal position of an adopted child under the KHI.
Islamic law also generally preserves the child’s biological lineage. Adoption does not transform the child into a biological child of the adoptive parents. The child’s relationship with the biological family is not simply erased.
This affects marriage guardianship and inheritance. An adoptive parent does not automatically become the child’s biological lineage-based guardian for marriage purposes. The appropriate guardian must be determined under Islamic law.
The adopted child also does not automatically inherit in the same way as a biological child. However, Article 209 of the KHI provides for a wasiat wajibah, or compulsory bequest, of up to one-third of the estate for an adopted child who does not receive a voluntary will. A similar provision applies to adoptive parents who do not receive a will from an adopted child.
This is a crucial distinction. You and I should not assume that adoption automatically produces the same inheritance rights as biological parentage. Estate planning through a will, gift, insurance, or other lawful arrangement may be needed.
The Correct Practical Process
If I were advising a family, I would recommend the following approach. First, identify the child’s legal status, biological parents, guardian, religion, age, health, and living circumstances. Second, confirm that the arrangement is genuinely voluntary and free from payment or coercion.
The prospective adoptive parents should prepare identity documents, marriage documents, financial information, health records, police clearance documents, and evidence of their ability to care for the child. Your lawyer at Wijaya & Co should then apply to the appropriate court. The court will focus on the child’s best interests, the suitability of the applicants, the biological parents’ consent, and the surrounding circumstances.
Only after the court issues its decision should the family complete the relevant civil registration and administrative updates. The adoption order should be kept securely with the child’s birth and identity documents.
Conclusion
Private adoption in Indonesia is not simply a private contract between adults. A direct family arrangement may begin informally, but legal adoption generally requires government involvement, and a court decision.
The Child Protection Law places the child’s welfare at the centre. The Marriage Law supports parental responsibility and family protection. The KHI explains the position of adopted children in Muslim families, particularly regarding lineage, guardianship, and wasiat wajibah under Article 209.
My strongest advice is not to rely on a private handover or a simple signed statement. If you and I want to protect the child properly, we should use the official process, preserve the child’s identity, avoid financial pressure, and plan for education, healthcare, divorce, inheritance, and future family relationships.
A lawful adoption may take longer than an informal arrangement, but it provides something much more valuable: stability, accountability, and protection for the child.
My name is Asep Wijaya, writing for Wijaya & Co. We orchestrate to assist you navigate. Thank you for reading my posts.
